Essay · · 1 min read
What a review is for
A second reader is there to find the question nobody asked.
I used to think a review was a gate: the work arrives, someone checks it against a list, and it passes or it doesn’t. Lists are useful. But a list only catches the mistakes you already know how to make.
The reviews that changed something were never about the list. They were one person saying, “wait, what happens if this is empty?” and the room going quiet. Nobody had asked. That question was the whole review.
So now the writer and the reader are never the same seat. Whoever built a thing can’t approve it, however careful they were. Careful is exactly when you stop seeing it.